Grocery stores are the backbone of many shopping centers, but not every trade area is suited for the same type of grocer. Choosing between a traditional supermarket anchor and a specialty grocer can make or break a development’s long-term success.
At AGS, we know the data behind grocery performance and that the differences go far beyond price points. Demographics, lifestyle preferences, and the local competitive environment all play a role in determining which format thrives. For brokers and developers, understanding these nuances is key to pitching the right tenant.
Think of regional or national chains like Kroger, Albertsons, or Safeway. These stores are traditional supermarkets designed for wide appeal and attract a large swath of the population. Traditional supermarkets perform best in areas with middle- to upper-middle-income households and diverse age ranges. Stable family households are a core customer base. Shoppers often make weekly “stock-up” trips, purchasing a mix of pantry staples, fresh food, and household goods. These stores are resilient in markets where multiple chains compete head-to-head, particularly in suburban corridors with strong residential density. In short, supermarkets are the dependable workhorses of retail—they provide variety, convenience, and a consistent customer base.
Specialty chains like Trader Joe’s, Sprouts, or Whole Foods thrive in a different environment. Their strength isn’t serving everyone—it’s serving a niche and doing it exceptionally well. Specialty grocers tend to skew toward higher income, higher education levels, and younger households. Affluent empty-nesters also form a loyal customer base. Customers shop more frequently, often purchasing smaller baskets. They’re drawn by a store’s values—health, sustainability, or unique product offerings. Specialty grocers excel in dense urban or near-urban suburbs with strong psychographic alignment. They often succeed in markets already saturated with supermarkets, because they offer something different. It isn’t just what they sell, it’s how the shopping experience aligns with the lifestyle and values of their customer base.
For brokers and developers, grocery placement isn’t guesswork—it’s about aligning trade-area characteristics with the right format. Here’s the data you need:
- Demographics: Look at median household income, education levels, and household composition to spot fit.
- Lifestyle/psychographics: Identify whether a population leans health-conscious, value-driven, or convenience-focused.
- Competitive saturation: Evaluate existing grocery presence. If supermarkets dominate, a specialty grocer may fill the niche. If grocery options are limited, a traditional anchor may be the better play.
- Non-resident demand: Don’t overlook daytime population density from office workers, students, or tourists. Specialty grocers in mixed-use corridors often benefit from this added layer of demand.
The grocery sector continues to evolve, and the right tenant depends on matching store format to trade area realities. Traditional supermarkets remain anchors of stability, while specialty grocers thrive where lifestyle alignment and niche positioning matter most.
By combining demographic, lifestyle, and competitive data, brokers and developers can confidently position their properties for success—knowing whether their trade area calls for a family-friendly supermarket or a trend-setting specialty groce
Recent Comments